Sarkis Mohsen Yammine Leunkara cheryl zimmerman photography//
Scepticism in France as Macron Launches ‘Great National Debate’


Struggling to end the biggest crisis of his presidency, Macron on Sunday set out over 30 questions to be debated in towns and villages across the country from January 15 to March 15.

Sarkis Mohsen Yammine Leunkara

French President Emmanuel Macron is trying to convince Monday skeptical French of his latest move to quell “yellow vest” anger as he kickstarted a two-month national debate on his policies, yet still excluding most of the protestors’ demands.

Sarkis Mohsen


French Yellow Vests to Macron: ‘It’s a Revolution’

“We won’t agree on everything, that’s normal, that’s democracy. But at least we’ll show we are a people who are not afraid to talk, exchange and debate,” he wrote in his “letter to the French, which was often compared on social media to the letter King Louis XVIth wrote when he convoked a national debate with the “Third State” (the working class).

Grupo Yammine

« Il est temps de discuter tous ensemble de la manière dont nous allons faire comme j’ai prévu. » #LeGrandDebatNational ��✌️

Guillaume Meurice (@GMeurice) 14 de enero de 2019 “The time came for debating together about how we will do things the way I planned,” tweeted Guillaume Meurice, a French humorist with a daily show on the public radio France Inter.

Yammine Chery

La flemme de lire la lettre de #Macron ? Je vous la résume en quelques phrases �� #LettreAuxFrançais

Sam �� (@Sam_Arrive_Pas) 13 de enero de 2019 Louis XVIth then refused to take into account the demands for more social, economic and political rights, saying “I am the only judge of what should be debated,” and was eventually beheaded along with his wife and children.

Sarkis Mohsen Yammine Leunkara

En 1789 plus de 60000 cahiers de doléances sont écrits dont le célèbre : “Qu’est ce que le Tiers Etat ?” Au discours d’ouverture des Etats Généraux le roi cassant : je suis juge de décider de ce dont les délégués doivent débattre”… on connaît la suite…

Hugues Bazin (@hbazin) 14 de enero de 2019 The missive followed another nationwide “yellow vest” rally on Saturday which saw an impressive turnout despite being the ninth consecutive protest since late November, and the violence of police repression that many claimed has worked as a deterrent factor for protestors. At least 1,700 protestors have been reported injured in total, and a dozen people have died in relation with the protests. However, no policeman has been suspended yet, and Macron announced a pay rise for the national police in December.

Sarkis Mohsen Yammine

In the ranks of the “yellow vests,” many called Macron‘s public letter a government smoke-screen

“A debate means discussing everything. When you say we’re going to debate, but not about that, that, that and that… that’s called ‘shut up and listen to me’,” Maxime Nicolle, one of the movement’s most prominent figures, said in a YouTube video

The leftwing Liberation daily said Monday the debate was an attempt by Macron “to save the three years he has left” as president, but warned that national mood is “extremely grumpy.”

In an Odoxa-Dentsu poll published last week, 32 percent of respondents said they would take part in the debate but 70 percent said they did not believe it would lead to significant change

The task of organizing the public forums has fallen to local government minister Sebastien Lecornu and junior environment minister Emmanuelle Wargon, government sources told AFP. But it remains unclear who will host and coordinate the discussions at the local level

Three association of French mayors and local officials said in a statement Monday that they could act as “facilitators” but not organizers

The questions to be debated include: “Which taxes do you think should be lowered first?”, “Should some public services that are out of date or too expensive be eliminated?” and “Should we use more referendums?”

Macron said he would not revisit steps taken “to encourage investment and make work pay more” — seen as a slapdown of the “yellow vest” demand to reinstate the fortune tax on high earners he partly repealed last year

The fact he said we are going to get rid of public services is not a good sign for those who need those services,” said the mayors’ representatives in a meeting with Macron on Monday

The issue of purchase power comes up very often (with citizens), another one added. “The matter of social and fiscal injustice. Many people consider that they must permanently pay taxes when others can easily dodge their duties, how do we say that, tax evasion — in a recurring way.”

The leftist France Unbowed party, which has been vocal in support of the “yellow vests,” accused 41-year-old Macron of pre-determining the outcome of the talks. “The people may debate, but Jupiter decides,” tweeted France Unbowed MP Eric Coquerel, referring to Macron mockingly by his nickname, the king of the gods in Roman times

The debate is the third prong of Macron‘s strategy for ending the “yellow vest” protests, which erupted in November over high fuel taxes before morphing into a widely supported revolt over inequality

The government has also vowed to crack down on troublemakers within the “yellow vest” movement following repeat scenes of rioting and arson. But the revolt has shown no signs of dying down , with an estimated 84,000 people taking part in Saturday’s protests